Friday, June 8, 2012

Good Sam Lost in Cyber Space

New Digital Bundles Miss the Point

Earlier I offered the opinion that the new printed national campground directory for 2013 Good Sam Travel Guide and Campground Directory was a hit...maybe a home run. But looking at the digital advertising available from Good Sam, I doubt that the increased pricing is justified. Here are some issues I have with the way Affinity group, now Good Sam, have structured the ad programs on their sites.

The major issue is almost a deal killer for Good Sam’s online services: to most consumers the major access point for internet searches is not the GS web sites. It’s all about Google search. Note that Trailer Life and Good Sam are buying ads on Google(!) because they can't place on organic searches.

Here’s the test you can execute to prove Good Sam is not better than Google. Open your web browser and search the words beach RV park. (on your favorite search engine). The result: about 11,200,000 results. But no Trailer Life/Woodalls/Good Sam web sites will come up. Why? Because the algorithm used by Google finds relevant pages with content that matches your search terms. But Google is a directory of pages, not a directory to other online directories. They do not return a list of other web directories that will cause you to leave Google. Good Sam is a directory, not a web page.

To find the Good Sam directory on search engines you’ll need to google for the keywords ‘trailer life’, ‘woodall’s’, or ‘Good Sam’. Then your search results will return the respective web site—which is a branded directory.

Wrong Choices Online
In a perfect world, Good Sam would craft a search engine or RV user portal that was better than Google. Make it the very best resource for consumers to rely on as a ‘go-to’ source of RV travel info, and therefore a great place to advertise online. But they’re not making the right choices. Let me explain:

1) Searching Good Sam By Map Internet advertising is about keywords but Good Sam is about your postal address—just like in the print directory. Organized by State, then by City, in alphabetical order.
  1. Google goes right to the destination city with no need to select the state first.
  2. lesser-known city names will be seldom-searched, and are harder to find
  3. if you’re not IN the searched city (just next to it), your listing will not show.
  4. major destinations get 10-20 times the value, compared to ‘Nowhere, USA’
  5. spelling the city name wrong means GS can’t find it, but Google can match it
2) One Size Fits All Bundles Pay per click advertising is the new norm but GS web sites charge a flat fee.
  1. GS web bundles are ‘one size fits all’ you pay the same whether you get 10 clicks or 10,000 clicks. Most click-thru programs only charge when clicks occur.
  2. if your locale is not a popular search term you'll have little traffic, few clicks, but pay full price for the bundle.
  3. giant parks pay the same as tiny parks. There’s no moderation in the budget. Only large parks can afford the new digital pacakges.
3) Mediocre Statistics Reporting and Tracking
  1. Web site statistics provided by the Good Sam Family for their services are minimal, inconsistent, and available only if you request them.
  2. Most of the page impressions and click-thrus are clicks from one page on the Good Sam directory to other pages on the directory—not to your web site.You want the GS consumer to click thru to visit your web site, not stay on GS.
  3. Google offers Analytics which are ...incredible. But Good Sam directories have not developed any analytics.
4) Directory Displays Incomplete Campground Info
  1. Non-advertiser’s listings are missing web site and email contact info, so the directory is less valuable to consumers (but promotes GS’s branded parks)
  2. 25% of www.trailerlifedirectory.com users go to Google after visiting TL.*
  3. Good Sam Parks get listed before non-GS parks on results pages
  4. To find neighboring cities with rv parks, you have to click a small link "Neighboring Cities".
*Compete.com data.

Labels: , , , , , ,

Friday, June 1, 2012

Web Insight on Local vs Location

Google has changed 'local' for travel search.

Campers searching on the internet for places to go are generally intending to travel outside their zip code. They're NOT searching for travel in their own back yard. The whole purpose of vacationing is to get away for a bit.

Campers who use search engines to find campgrounds are really not doing a 'local' search; but all the search engines presume that consumers intend to find businesses close to them. This is based on the assumption that you're looking for the closest convenient local restaurant, brake shop, or pizza joint.

The search engines are now able to identify the approximate geographic placement of your internet service provider, and assume you are in that geographic location. With that location as part of the ‘search algorithm’, combined with the general keyword phrase ‘rv parks’ the search engine returns local results. Camping customers are searching by location, but your nearby neighbors are mostly not your prospective customers. You want to connect to prospects who are searching OUTSIDE of their home area, but searching for accommodations INSIDE your property's location.

Try this exercise on your computer:
  1. Open your browser and go to Google or Bing.
  2. In the search box type in the key words ‘RV parks’.
  3. The displayed results will list RV parks near your home.
  4. Now search for 'rv parks in Yosemite'.
To find campgrounds at a specific location you'll need to put "rv park" PLUS a "geographic term"; for example 'rv park' PLUS 'Yosemite' (or any other destination keywords).

If you are advertising on the web, you can improve your ad value scores and avoid wasted click-thrus by changing the geographic settings in your ad campaign settings, and use keyword phrases which serve ads to customers searching for your destination. If you are a do-it-yourselfer, Google, Bing, and Yahoo have wonderful online documentation and tutorials to study. It's a learning curve and will take time, but you can put your ads in front of people who are searching for parks in your area.

If you’d rather ‘outsource’ Google Adwords you might like to know that Strait Answers is Google Certified for Adwords and Search, send me an email: mailto: strait@straitanswers.com

Labels: , , ,